Text Size

Current Size: 100%

Street drinkers who killed and dismembered friend’s body are jailed

Four homeless street drinkers who were invited into the home of a Northampton man who they then savagely killed and partially dismembered have been jailed.

Ian Cuthbertson, aged 51, Michael Hallett, aged 59, Joseph Catlin, aged 31, and Zena Kane, aged 36, all of no fixed address, were sentenced today at Northampton Crown Court after being found guilty by a jury.

Hallett, Catlin, and Kane were found guilty of murder and sentenced to life. They will serve a minimum of 23 years, 18 years and 20 years respectively.

Cuthbertson was found guilty of manslaughter and jailed for seven and a half years, half of which will be in custody. 

All four will have the 393 days they have already served on remand deduced from their sentences.

On Tuesday, 14 June, 2016 at just after 5pm, officers attended 24 Patterdale Walk, Boothville, Northampton, where in the bedroom they discovered the body of David Miller, aged 56.

During the trial relaying what officers discovered after entry to the flat, Peter Joyce QC for the prosecution said: “He had been the victim of a brutal and sustained assault in his bedroom and had died of a stab wound to his heart.

“His body had been covered in porridge oats as well as the ashes of his own mother.”

During the investigation, detectives discovered a series of items that had been used as weapons on David’s body including, a cork screws, different types of knives, broken glass, an angle grinder, scissors, rolling pin, chisel and a saw.

The prosecution case stated that all four had been involved in the attack that had taken place in the late evening of Friday, 10 June and into the hours of the Saturday.

And that in those four days that followed they had made crude attempts to butcher and dispose of David’s body, including a substantial wound to his head in an attempt to remove it.

The jury were told how David, who was well known and liked in Patterdale Walk, had been friends with Catlin for a few years.

Catlin, who had drink and drug issues with long spells of being homeless, and had been allowed by David to stay in his flat.

CCTV footage shown to the jury revealed the movements of the four defendants before and after they had killed David, including an image of Kane where she could be seen wearing white shoes before David was killed and then red shoes afterwards.

The jury were shown computer generated images of the body and the crime scene due to the graphic nature of the assault.

The pathologist, Dr Stuart Hamilton, gave evidence that David had suffered 15 stab wound to his back and a number to the front of his body including the fatal stab to his heart.

He had suffered injuries pre and post mortem.

The gang were arrested after officers attended an incident in Northampton Market Square at around 3.30am on Tuesday, 14 June.

Officers on the scene were confronted by a drunken Hallett who said he wanted to be locked up. When asked by the officer why, he responded, murder. He said that it was a man called David and that he had been chopped up.

The officer was unable to get Hallett to give an address. He was then put into a police car and instructed to direct officers to the location.

After officers forced entry to David’s flat, Hallett was arrested and the remaining defendants were subsequently arrested that day.

Cuthbertson had argued that while he had been in the flat, they had all taken a load of pills and that he had fallen asleep on the coach and had no knowledge of what happened.

Kane gave an account that she did not see the assault and that she was in the living room but too afraid to go into the bedroom or intervene.

Catlin claimed he hadn’t been in the flat for two weeks and had no knowledge of the murder.

Peter James QC, said: “These four defendants all took part in the brutal killing of a vulnerable man in his own home and then spend days trying to cover up their actions.”

Detective Inspector Phil Mills, who led the investigation, said: “These four people preyed on a vulnerable member of the community, someone who was known and liked by his neighbours.

“They worked their way into his home and took advantage of his good nature.

“The depravity in what they did to him is unimaginable. And instead of coming forward, they tried to cover up their actions and then lied about their involvement.

“This was a challenging investigation for all those involved and I would like to thank the officers for their hard work.

“I would also like to thank all the witnesses who came forward and provided evidence, many of them in challenging circumstances.

“While nothing could alleviate the pain caused by this crime to the family of David Miller, I hope this verdict means they can get some form of closure in their lives.”

This statement is made on behalf of the family of the late David Miller.

“We as a family are devastated by the horrific murder of our brother David, and the appalling things that happened to his body following his death.

“David was a generous, loving, caring person who has never harmed anyone.

“His brutal killers heartlessly exploited David's vulnerability, and we as a family will never forget what has been done to David, and the desecration of our Mother's memory.”

Det Insp Phil Mills speaks following the sentencing of Cuthbertson, Hallett, Catlin and Kane
CCTV footage of Cuthbertson, Hallett, Catlin and Kane
Back to Top